Home/Guides/MTG/Best Marvel Super Heroes Commanders

Commander rankings · Marvel Super Heroes

The 10 best Marvel Super Heroes commanders.

Marvel Super Heroes gave Commander players explosive combat engines, artifact combo shells, and an indestructible planet-eater. We ranked the legends by pressure, velocity, staying power, and how quickly each can turn one opening into a winning position.

1
Scarlet Witch, Chaotic Avenger extended-art Magic: The Gathering card

Best overall · Explosive combat engine

Scarlet Witch, Chaotic Avenger

One clean hit can start a chain of free spells, extra combats, and extra turns.

Whenever Scarlet Witch deals combat damage to a player, she adds the top two cards of your library to a face-down pool, then casts a Hero or noncreature spell from that pool for free. The cards remain available to the same Scarlet Witch across later triggers, so every successful attack improves the next one.

Blue-red is exactly where this ability wants to be. Haste gets her moving immediately; top-deck setup improves every pair of cards; double strike, extra combats, and extra turns create more triggers. A single connection can cast the spell that creates the next combat, which creates the next free spell, and suddenly the deck is chaining damage turn after turn.

Build towardHaste, protection, top-deck control, double strike, extra combats, and extra turns.
Pressure pointShe is a 3/3 that must connect, and a new copy cannot use cards exiled by the old one.
TCG Spikes tracked priceSee tracked price

Loading the matching printing from our card page…

2
Iron Man, Bleeding Edge Magic: The Gathering card

Best artifact value engine

Iron Man, Bleeding Edge

Copy the right artifact every turn, not just on your own turn.

Iron Man copies the first artifact spell you choose each turn. The simple floor is excellent: double a mana rock, value artifact, or threat. The ceiling rises sharply when the deck can cast artifacts at instant speed, letting Iron Man produce value around the whole table.

Five mana means you want cheap protection and a curve that can deploy an artifact immediately after he resolves. Once the engine is online, though, it generates real cards and mana without asking Iron Man to attack.

Build towardFlash enablers, efficient artifacts, artifact cost reduction, and token payoffs.
Pressure pointFive mana plus a follow-up spell makes the first turn resource-intensive.
TCG Spikes tracked priceSee tracked price

Loading the matching printing from our card page…

3
Shuri, Wakandan Inventor Magic: The Gathering card

Best low-cost combo commander

Shuri, Wakandan Inventor

Two mana buys a cost reducer and a dangerous artifact-copy tool.

Shuri comes down early, discounts every artifact spell, and can temporarily turn one artifact into a nonlegendary copy of another. That is an unusually dense package for two mana and makes commander tax much easier to absorb than it is for the splashier five- and six-mana legends.

The copy ability is sorcery-speed and needs two artifacts, but it rewards careful sequencing and opens a deep library of blue artifact interactions. She is the commander here most likely to look harmless until a utility artifact suddenly becomes the best permanent on the battlefield.

Build towardCheap artifacts, high-impact copy targets, untap effects, and artifact combos.
Pressure pointThe one-toughness body needs protection from incidental damage.
TCG Spikes tracked priceSee tracked price

Loading the matching printing from our card page…

4
Mister Fantastic Magic: The Gathering card

Best four-color toolbox

Mister Fantastic

A three-mana commander with four-color access and a late-game ability worth building around.

At the beginning of combat on your turn, Mister Fantastic draws a card if you cast a noncreature spell that turn. His activated ability then copies one triggered ability you control twice, turning the right enter-the-battlefield or attack trigger into a decisive swing.

The real advantage is flexibility: his color identity includes red, green, white, and blue even though he costs only three blue mana to cast. You can build a Fantastic Four theme, a triggered-ability toolbox, or a polished value deck without asking the commander to carry every turn.

Build towardPremium triggered abilities, noncreature cantrips, untap effects, and flexible answers.
Pressure pointThe triple-copy activation costs four colors and requires Mister Fantastic to tap.
TCG Spikes tracked priceSee tracked price

Loading the matching printing from our card page…

5
Thor, God of Thunder Magic: The Gathering card

Best mono-red spell engine

Thor, God of Thunder

Every noncreature spell becomes direct damage, while Thor recovers the best spell on entry.

Whenever you cast a noncreature spell, Thor deals damage equal to that spell's mana value to any target. That turns ramp, removal, Equipment, and big red spells into a second layer of interaction or a direct route to closing the game.

His enter-the-battlefield ability also exiles an Equipment, instant, or sorcery from your graveyard and lets you play it through the end of your next turn. The card remains in exile rather than moving to your hand, but it still gives Thor a real follow-up and rewards recasting him.

Build towardMana-positive rocks, high-value noncreature spells, Equipment, graveyard setup, and damage multipliers.
Pressure pointFive mana is a meaningful setup cost, and mono-red limits protection and stack interaction.
TCG Spikes tracked priceSee tracked price

Loading the matching printing from our card page…

6
Ultron, Artificial Malevolence Magic: The Gathering card

Best colorless artifact swarm

Ultron, Artificial Malevolence

Turn every useful artifact into another useful artifact—and a Robot.

Whenever another nontoken artifact enters under your control, Ultron can copy it for two mana. If the copy was not already a creature, it also becomes a 2/2 Robot Villain. Copying mana rocks helps pay for later triggers; copying utility artifacts creates a board that scales in both value and combat pressure.

The creature clause is both the appeal and the risk. Your copied artifacts can attack, receive Robot support, and close games, but they also become vulnerable to creature sweepers. The best lists will lean into that tension instead of pretending it does not exist.

Build towardArtifacts with strong static or tap abilities, token support, and recursion.
Pressure pointColorless deck-building and creature wipes can punish an overextended Robot board.
TCG Spikes tracked priceSee tracked price

Loading the matching printing from our card page…

7
Black Widow, Agile Avenger Magic: The Gathering card

Best Boros card-advantage commander

Black Widow, Agile Avenger

Let opponents draw—then make sure you profit more than they do.

Black Widow draws you a card and gains a +1/+1 counter whenever an opponent draws their second card in a turn. Because each opponent can trigger her separately, group-draw effects and wheels can turn an ordinary table cycle into a surge of cards and commander-damage pressure.

She gives red-white a clean engine from the command zone without demanding a narrow creature type. The tradeoff is political: helping the table draw can accelerate an opponent into the answer they need, so the strongest build controls when the extra cards arrive.

Build towardSymmetrical draw, wheels, combat evasion, and +1/+1 counter payoffs.
Pressure pointWithout extra-draw enablers, opponents can simply limit her triggers.
TCG Spikes tracked priceSee tracked price

Loading the matching printing from our card page…

8
Doctor Doom, King of Latveria Magic: The Gathering card

Best Villain discard commander

Doctor Doom, King of Latveria

A Grixis looting engine that turns discarded lands into damage.

Doom makes a Villain connive at the beginning of combat on your turn and gives that creature menace for the turn. Doom is himself a Villain, so this ability functions without another Villain on the battlefield. The connive improves card quality and feeds Doom's first ability: discarding one or more lands makes every opponent lose 2 life.

The face commander of Doom Prevails does not need to attack, and Grixis supplies excellent discard and graveyard support without requiring an unrealistically deep Villain roster. The damage arrives in fixed increments, so treat it as pressure that supports a broader plan rather than the deck's only way to win.

Build towardVillains, land-heavy draw engines, discard payoffs, and graveyard value.
Pressure pointOne connive per combat is steady, but not explosive without other discard effects.
TCG Spikes tracked priceSee tracked price

Loading the matching printing from our card page…

9
Molecule Man Magic: The Gathering card

Highest miracle ceiling

Molecule Man

A spectacular zero-mana miracle engine gated by the first card you draw each turn.

Molecule Man gives nonland cards in your hand miracle {0}. Miracle applies to a card as you draw it and only if it is the first card you drew that turn; it does not let you cast every nonland already in hand. Top-deck setup and instant-speed draw can create one free-cast window on each opponent's turn as well as your own.

Six mana buys no enter-the-battlefield or board effect. If the deck cannot draw on opposing turns, the table may get a full round before your next draw step; with the right draw engine, however, Molecule Man can produce value on the next player's turn. That ceiling is balanced by the conditional first-draw window and colorless deck-building.

Build towardTop-deck control, draw on every turn, massive colorless threats, and protection.
Pressure pointSix mana, no immediate value, a once-per-turn miracle window, and colorless deck-building.
TCG Spikes tracked priceSee tracked price

Loading the matching printing from our card page…

10
Captain America, Team Leader Magic: The Gathering card

Best Hero typal commander

Captain America, Team Leader

Every new Hero enters ready to fight and leaves two permanent counters behind.

Captain America gives each other Hero vigilance and haste for the turn it enters, then puts a +1/+1 counter on that Hero and on himself. That is exactly what a typal commander should do: reward the deck's natural card choices, shorten the setup turn, and turn every creature into permanent board growth.

Jeskai colors cover interaction, card draw, and many of the set's Avengers. He is more exposed to sweepers than the value engines higher on this list, but he is the cleanest choice for a player whose first priority is assembling a recognizable Marvel team.

Build towardLow-curve Heroes, enter-the-battlefield effects, counter synergies, and protection.
Pressure pointThe deck wants a wide battlefield and can lose momentum to repeated sweepers.
TCG Spikes tracked priceSee tracked price

Loading the matching printing from our card page…

Honorable mentions

These missed the top ten because they are narrower, slower, or less self-contained—not because they lack a compelling deck.

Reed Richards, Smartest Man Magic card

Extra-draw engine

Reed Richards, Smartest Man

Reed replaces the first extra card you would draw each turn with four cards and removes your maximum hand size. Instant-speed draw can trigger him around the table, giving mono-blue a huge self-contained engine without a typal requirement.

Tracked priceSee tracked price

Loading market data…

Shang-Chi, Master of Kung Fu Magic card

Creature ability combo

Shang-Chi, Master of Kung Fu

He gives your creatures' activated abilities virtual haste and taps for two mana toward those abilities. Mono-green limits the toolbox, but the commander is efficient and combo-ready.

Tracked priceSee tracked price

Loading market data…

Namor the Sub-Mariner Magic card

Spells meet Merfolk

Namor the Sub-Mariner

Blue-heavy noncreature spells create Merfolk while the growing team increases Namor's power. It is a clean bridge between typal and spellslinger decks.

Tracked priceSee tracked price

Loading market data…

Mister Fantastic, Reed Richards Magic card

Efficient token draw

Mister Fantastic, Reed Richards

Reed draws whenever one or more tokens enter under your control. Each batch is one trigger, but separate token-entry events can trigger him repeatedly with no mana payment or combat requirement.

Tracked priceSee tracked price

Loading market data…

Director Nick Fury Magic card

Hero cost reduction

Director Nick Fury

A one-mana discount for Heroes plus a top-four Hero selection trigger whenever you attack. Less explosive than Captain America, but arguably the steadier tribal engine.

Tracked priceSee tracked price

Loading market data…